Volume 37 - Article 20 | Pages 635–668  

The effect of the Great Recession on permanent childlessness in Italy

By Marcantonio Caltabiano, Chiara Ludovica Comolli, Alessandro Rosina

Abstract

Background: The Great Recession had a strong effect not only on the economy of developed countries but also on family dynamics. Many studies investigate how the crisis affected fertility behavior, but the link between economic shocks and childbearing is still debated.

Objective: Most studies argue that fertility responds to recessions with only a temporary postponement of first births by young women. A paper by Comolli and Bernardi (2015), though, finds a permanent positive effect of the Great Recession in the United States on childlessness among women in their late thirties. In light of these results, we test whether a similar effect is found in a different context, i.e., Italy.

Methods: We apply the difference-in-difference method to synthetic cohorts of Italian childless women in their late thirties to assess whether the crisis had a permanent impact on the cohorts’ childlessness rates. We use the Istat 2004–2013 Italian Labor Force Survey (LFS).

Results: During the Great Recession in Italy, contrary to the United States, childlessness among women around the age of 40 registered short-term negative fluctuations. Only mid-educated women seem to have slightly postponed first births during the crisis.

Contribution: This paper contributes to the debate on how economic shocks affect fertility, with the objective of assessing whether the recent Great Recession had a permanent effect on childlessness in Italy. The main conclusion is that, except for the group of women with average education, the crisis did not increase permanent childlessness among Italian women beyond its preexisting positive long-term trend.

Author's Affiliation

• Marcantonio Caltabiano - Università degli Studi di Messina (UNIME), Italy EMAIL
• Chiara Ludovica Comolli - Università di Bologna (UNIBO), Italy EMAIL
• Alessandro Rosina - Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Lowest-Low Fertility: Signs of a recovery in Italy?
Volume 21 - Article 23

Interdependence between sexual debut and church attendance in Italy
Volume 14 - Article 19

Leaving and returning to the parental home during COVID times in France, Italy, Germany, Spain, and the United Kingdom
Volume 50 - Article 3

Diverse pathways in young Italians’ entrance into sexual life: The association with gender and birth cohort
Volume 46 - Article 13

Couples' paid work, state-level unemployment, and first births in the United States
Volume 45 - Article 38

The impact of COVID-19 on fertility plans in Italy, Germany, France, Spain, and the United Kingdom
Volume 43 - Article 47

Traditional versus Facebook-based surveys: Evaluation of biases in self-reported demographic and psychometric information
Volume 42 - Article 5

The fertility response to the Great Recession in Europe and the United States: Structural economic conditions and perceived economic uncertainty
Volume 36 - Article 51

Intergenerational family ties and the diffusion of cohabitation in Italy
Volume 16 - Article 14

Is marriage losing its centrality in Italy?
Volume 11 - Article 6

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

The importance of education for understanding variability of dementia onset in the United States
Volume 50 - Article 26    | Keywords: dementia, education, lifespan variability, modal age, morbidity compression

Measuring the educational gradient of period fertility in 28 European countries: A new approach based on parity-specific fertility estimates
Volume 49 - Article 34    | Keywords: education, Europe, period fertility, quantum, tempo, total fertility rate (TFR)

A Bayesian model for the reconstruction of education- and age-specific fertility rates: An application to African and Latin American countries
Volume 49 - Article 31    | Keywords: age, Bayesian analysis, education, fertility estimation, fertility rates

Educational reproduction in Sweden: A replication of Skopek and Leopold 2020 using Swedish data
Volume 48 - Article 25    | Keywords: differential fertility, education, prospective models, reproduction, social mobility, Sweden

Delayed first births and completed fertility across the 1940–1969 birth cohorts
Volume 48 - Article 15    | Keywords: age at first birth, childlessness, completed cohort fertility, decomposition, fertility postponement, fertility recuperation, low-fertility