Volume 28 - Article 33 | Pages 951–980  

The more you learn the less you know? Interpretive ambiguity across three modes of qualitative data

By Nicole Angotti, Amy Kaler


Background: Researchers across disciplines face a similar challenge ensuring our methods can give us valid, usable answers to our questions. But what happens when multiple strategies of inquiry give us different answers to the same research question? We explore this issue through three different modes of qualitative inquiry - interviews, focus groups, and participant observation - oriented around local attitudes to HIV testing.

Objective: We introduce the notion of "research awareness" - the extent to which participants are continuously reminded that they are taking part in a research project, which is a function of the mode of research itself. We hypothesize that as participants’ research-awareness decreases across modes, from interviews to focus groups to participant observation, the proportion of statements that conform to officially sanctioned normative discourse about HIV/AIDS will decrease and the proportion expressing non-normative or counter-normative ideas will increase.

Methods: We tabulated positive and negative references to three themes - knowing one’s HIV status, counseling messages, and antiretroviral treatment - across the three qualitative modes.

Results: The distribution is non-uniform, with favorable responses to testing themes predominating in interviews, mixed responses in the focus groups, and negative responses predominating in the observational data. At least a third of references to testing across all three modes, however, do not support officially sanctioned normative discourse.

Conclusions: Researchers who use mixed methods approaches for triangulation should consider the influence of research-awareness on their methods. These situational specifics are crucial for understanding the applicability of research to real life. Substantively, our study revealed a robust level of ambivalence about HIV testing despite normative discourses supporting it at local and global levels.

Author's Affiliation

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Working with teams of "insiders": Qualitative approaches to data collection in the Global South
Volume 32 - Article 12

Asking God about the date you will die: HIV testing as a zone of uncertainty in rural Malawi
Volume 23 - Article 32

"My Girlfriends Could Fill A Yanu-Yanu Bus": Rural Malawian Men's Claims About Their Own Serostatus
Special Collection 1 - Article 11

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Better to ask online when it concerns intimate relationships? Survey mode differences in the assessment of relationship quality
Volume 48 - Article 22    | Keywords: data collection, Generations and Gender Programme (GGP), interviews, intimate relationship, quality of a statistical survey, relationships, research methods, survey data

A probabilistic model for analyzing summary birth history data
Volume 47 - Article 11    | Keywords: Bayesian hierarchical model, Brass method, Malawi, spatial smoothing, temporal smoothing

To what extent were life expectancy gains in South Africa attributable to declines in HIV/AIDS mortality from 2006 to 2017? A life table analysis of age-specific mortality
Volume 46 - Article 18    | Keywords: antiretroviral therapy, HIV/AIDS, life expectancy, South Africa

Women’s health decline following (some) unintended births: A prospective study
Volume 45 - Article 17    | Keywords: fertility, Malawi, panel studies, unintended fertility, women's health

Marital dissolutions and changes in mental health: Evidence from rural Malawi
Volume 44 - Article 41    | Keywords: divorce, Malawi, marriage, mental health, widowhood