Volume 29 - Article 1 | Pages 1–32  

Citizenship Reporting in the American Community Survey

By Jennifer Van Hook, James Bachmeier

Abstract

Background: Citizenship status among the foreign born is a crucial indicator of social and political incorporation, yet there are good reasons to suspect that citizenship status is inaccurately reported on U.S. surveys.

Objective: This paper updates research carried out in the mid-1990s by Passel and Clark (1997) on the extent to which foreign-born noncitizen respondents in U.S. government-sponsored surveys misreport as naturalized citizens.

Methods: We compare demographic estimates of the resident naturalized foreign-born population in 2010, based on administrative data, to estimates from the 2010 American Community Survey (ACS).

Results: Similar to previous research, we find that misreporting in the ACS is especially high among immigrants from all countries/regions who report fewer than five years in the United States. We also find that among longer-term foreign-born residents, misreporting is concentrated only among those originating in Mexico, especially men of all ages and older women, a finding that diverges from Passel and Clark in that we find no evidence of overreporting among immigrants from Central America and the Caribbean. Finally, the estimated magnitude of misreporting, especially among longer-term Mexican-born men, is sensitive to assumptions about the rate of emigration in our administrative-based demographic estimates, and assumptions about coverage error in the ACS, though altering these assumptions does not change the conclusions drawn from the general patterns of the results.

Conclusions: For applications that use citizenship as an indicator of legal status, we recommend that self-reported data on citizenship be accepted at face value for all groups except those with fewer than five years of U.S. residence, Mexican men, and older Mexican women.

Author's Affiliation

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Legal status and health disparities: An examination of health insurance coverage among the foreign-born
Volume 47 - Article 16

A framework for the prospective analysis of ethno-cultural super-diversity
Volume 41 - Article 11

The weight of school entry: Weight gain among Hispanic children of immigrants during the elementary school years
Volume 40 - Article 5

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Reducing uncertainty in Delphi surveys: A case study on immigration to the EU
Volume 49 - Article 36    | Keywords: European Union, immigration, international migration, migration flows

Ultra-Orthodox fertility and marriage in the United States: Evidence from the American Community Survey
Volume 49 - Article 29    | Keywords: age at first marriage, American Community Survey (ACS), fertility, Judaism, marriage, religion, total fertility rate (TFR), Ultra-Orthodox Judaism

Legal status and health disparities: An examination of health insurance coverage among the foreign-born
Volume 47 - Article 16    | Keywords: health insurance, immigration, imputation, legal status

Multiple (il)legal pathways: The diversity of immigrants' legal trajectories in Belgium
Volume 47 - Article 10    | Keywords: Belgium, immigration, integration, legal status, population register, sequence analysis, trajectories

Family changes and residential mobility among immigrant and native-born populations: Evidence from Swiss administrative data
Volume 43 - Article 41    | Keywords: family transitions, immigration, life course, residential mobility