Volume 40 - Article 10 | Pages 261–278  

Identifying interaction effects using random fertility shocks

By Rannveig Hart, Sara Cools

Abstract

Background: Fertility interaction effects in social networks increasingly attracts the interest of demographers. While these theories propose a causal mechanism, they are rarely put to test in a plausibly causal statistical design.

Objective: We aim to differentiate network effects from selection by using an instrumental variable (IV) approach to achieve exogenous variation in fertility. We use interaction effects between siblings as an empirical example.

Methods: We draw data from Norwegian administrative registers (N ∼ 170,000 men and women). We use twin births and children’s sex composition as random fertility shocks (IVs), generating exogenous variation in third births.

Results: In our full study sample, we find no significant effects on ego’s fertility of random shocks to the propensity to have three children. Subgroup analysis by sex and parity indicates positive effects for firstborn women when the sibling’s birth is intended (as captured by the same-sex instrument). We find no evidence that similarity strengthens interaction effects.

Conclusions: The study contributes to the literature by testing long-standing hypotheses of fertility interaction effects in a plausibly causal design. With the exception of firstborn women, we find no evidence of interaction effects of a sibling’s third birth.

Contribution: The study contributes to the literature by testing long-standing hypotheses of fertility contagion for the first time in a plausibly causal design. With the exception of first born women, we find no evidence of contagion effects.

Author's Affiliation

• Rannveig Hart - Statistisk sentralbyrå (Statistics Norway), Norway EMAIL
• Sara Cools - Institutt for samfunnsforskning (Institute for Social Research), Norway EMAIL

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Ultra-Orthodox fertility and marriage in the United States: Evidence from the American Community Survey
Volume 49 - Article 29    | Keywords: age at first marriage, American Community Survey (ACS), fertility, Judaism, marriage, religion, total fertility rate (TFR), Ultra-Orthodox Judaism

Advanced or postponed motherhood? Migrants’ and natives’ gap between ideal and actual age at first birth in Spain
Volume 49 - Article 22    | Keywords: actual age at first birth, age at arrival, fertility, ideal age at first birth, international migration, motherhood, Spain

Describing the Dutch Social Networks and Fertility Study and how to process it
Volume 49 - Article 19    | Keywords: fertility, Netherlands, personal networks, social influence

Partial fertility recuperation in Spain two years after the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic
Volume 49 - Article 17    | Keywords: COVID-19, fertility, recuperation, Spain

The quality of fertility data in the web-based Generations and Gender Survey
Volume 49 - Article 3    | Keywords: accuracy, data quality, fertility, Generations and Gender Survey (GGS)