Volume 40 - Article 4 | Pages 61–94  

The Healthy Immigrant Effect: The role of educational selectivity in the good health of migrants

By Mathieu Ichou, Matthew Wallace


Background: The Healthy Immigrant Effect (HIE) refers to the fact that recent migrants are in better health than the nonmigrant population in the host country. Central to explaining the HIE is the idea that migrants are positively selected in terms of their socioeconomic and health characteristics when compared to nonmigrants in their country of origin. However, due to a lack of reliable and comparable data, most existing studies rely on socioeconomic and health measures as collected in the host country after migration and do not actually measure selection.

Objective: We directly test selection as an explanation of the HIE among migrants living in France.

Methods: Using the French Trajectories and Origins (TeO) survey and Barro‒Lee dataset, we construct a direct measure of migrants’ educational selectivity. We then test its effect on health differences between migrants and nonmigrants using measures self-rated health, health limitations, and chronic illnesses, by fitting logistic regression and Karlson‒Holm‒Breen (KHB) decompositions.

Results: After demonstrating that migrants in France experience an HIE, especially males, we also show that educational level as measured in the host country cannot account for the HIE. By contrast, we provide important evidence that educational selectivity constitutes a significant factor in explaining health disparities between migrant and nonmigrant populations.

Contribution: Capitalizing on a novel measure of migrants' educational selectivity, we give credit to the oft-cited but rarely tested theory that the HIE is a consequence of migrants' positive selection.

Author's Affiliation

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Lives saved, lives lost, and under-reported COVID-19 deaths: Excess and non-excess mortality in relation to cause-specific mortality during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic in Sweden
Volume 50 - Article 1

Adult mortality among second-generation immigrants in France: Results from a nationally representative record linkage study
Volume 40 - Article 54

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

The gender gap in schooling outcomes: A cohort study of young men and women in India
Volume 48 - Article 33    | Keywords: cohort studies, educational attainment, gender, India, secondary education

The question of the human mortality plateau: Contrasting insights by longevity pioneers
Volume 48 - Article 11    | Keywords: age, France, Gompertz mortality, mortality, mortality plateau, older population, parametric models, supercentenarians, survival analysis, trajectories

Do the consequences of parental separation for children’s educational success vary by parental education? The role of educational thresholds
Volume 47 - Article 28    | Keywords: divorce, educational attainment, family, Germany, interaction, resource compensation, separation, sibling fixed effects

Who took care of what? The gender division of unpaid work during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic in France
Volume 46 - Article 34    | Keywords: COVID-19, France, gender equality, panel studies, unpaid work

Variation in the educational consequences of parental death and divorce: The role of family and country characteristics
Volume 46 - Article 20    | Keywords: divorce rate, educational attainment, educational system, parental death, parental divorce, parental resources, tracking, welfare state