Volume 45 - Article 11 | Pages 345–360  

Using multiple cause of death information to eliminate garbage codes

By Agnieszka Fihel, Magdalena Muszynska-Spielauer

Abstract

Background: International comparisons of mortality largely depend on the quality of data. With more than 20% of deaths annually assigned to ill-defined cardiovascular conditions, the mortality level due to well-defined causes of death is under-registered in Poland.

Objective: We aim to reclassify cardiovascular garbage codes (GCs) into well-defined causes based on multiple causes of death (MCoD) data and to approximate mortality levels due to well-defined causes of death in Poland. We examine the usefulness of the MCoD approach for correcting low-quality data on causes of death.

Methods: Based on the unique MCoD dataset for Poland, death counts due to cardiovascular GCs were reassigned to well-defined underlying causes in two steps: (1) manually for death records that included MCoD information constituting a logical chain of conditions leading to death and (2) with coarsened exact matching for the remaining death records. Age-specific and age-standardised death rates for large groups of causes were calculated before and after redistribution and compared to those of other Eastern European countries with relatively good data quality.

Results: Of deaths originally assigned to cardiovascular GCs, 86,856 were reclassified, mostly to well-defined cardiovascular diseases, cancers, endocrine, nutritional and metabolic diseases, and respiratory diseases. The age-standardised death rate due to well-defined ischaemic heart diseases increased by 43%, and the rate due to cerebrovascular diseases by 22%. Cardiovascular mortality structure by large groups of causes became similar to the structure registered in other Eastern European countries characterised by a low prevalence of GCs.

Conclusions: Coarsened exact matching performs relatively well when abundant MCoD information is available and enhances the comparability of cause-of-death data between countries.

Contribution: Redistribution of GCs improves the quality of cause-of-death data and enhances their comparability between countries.

Author’s Affiliation

• Agnieszka Fihel - Uniwersytet Warszawski, Poland EMAIL
• Magdalena Muszynska-Spielauer - Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Austria EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Bringing cause-of-death analysis into demography: An interview with France Meslé
Volume 54 - Article 24

The distortion of fertility due to migration: A comparative analysis of migrants in the Netherlands and stayers in Poland
Volume 53 - Article 12

The direct and indirect impact of international migration on the population ageing process: A formal analysis and its application to Poland
Volume 38 - Article 43

Minor gradient in mortality by education at the highest ages: An application of the Extinct-Cohort method
Volume 29 - Article 19

Women’s employment and union dissolution in a changing socio-economic context in Russia
Volume 18 - Article 6

Migration and union dissolution in a changing socio-economic context: The case of Russia
Volume 17 - Article 27

Similar articles in Demographic Research

Diversity in causes of death: A new framework to account for multiple causes of death
Volume 55 - Article 20    | Keywords: diversity, life table, multiple causes of death

Migrant mortality across contexts and generations: A comparative study of Norway and England and Wales
Volume 55 - Article 18    | Keywords: assimilation, cross-national comparison, England, migrant descendants, migrant mortality, migrant mortality, mortality, Norway, second generation, Wales

Estimating COVID-19 excess mortality during and after the pandemic: A Bayesian model, with an application to New Zealand
Volume 55 - Article 17    | Keywords: Bayesian analysis, COVID-19, mortality, mortality forecasting, New Zealand, New Zealand

A personal perspective on the history of the World Fertility Survey and The Demographic and Health Surveys Program: An interview with Tom Pullum
Volume 55 - Article 6    | Keywords: Demographic Health Surveys, fertility, fertility, health, mortality, surveys, World Fertility Survey

Collecting data on HIV/AIDS mortality during household surveys: A randomized validation study in Malawi
Volume 54 - Article 41    | Keywords: data quality, excess mortality, HIV/AIDS, mortality, siblings, social desirability bias, surveys