Volume 55 - Article 18 | Pages 533–572
Migrant mortality across contexts and generations: A comparative study of Norway and England and Wales
By Joseph Harrison, Frank Sullivan, Katherine Keenan, Øystein Kravdal, Hill Kulu
References
Abraido-Lanza, A.F., Dohrenwend, B.P., Ng-Mak, D.S., Blake Turner, J., and Abraido-Lanza, A.F. (1999). The Latino mortality paradox: A test of the ‘Salmon Bias’ and healthy migrant hypotheses. American Journal of Public Health 89(10): 1543–1548.
Aldridge, R.W., Nellums, L.B., Bartlett, S., Barr, A.L., Patel, P., Burns, R., Hargreaves, S., Miranda, J.J., Tollman, S., Friedland, J.S., and Abubakar, I. (2018). Global patterns of mortality in international migrants: A systematic review and meta-analysis. The Lancet 392(10164): 2553–2566.
Antecol, H. and Bedard, K. (2006). Unhealthy assimilation: Why do immigrants converge to American health status levels? Demography 43(2): 337–360.
Bambra, C. (2011). Health inequalities and welfare state regimes: Theoretical insights on a public health ‘puzzle’. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 65(9): 740–745.
Bambra, C., Netuveli, G., and Eikemo, T. (2010). Welfare state regime life courses: The development of Western European welfare state regimes and age-related patterns of educational inequalities in self-reported health. International Journal of Health Services 40(3): 399–420.
Bodewes, A.J., Agyemang, C., and Kunst, A.E. (2019). All-cause mortality among three generations of Moluccans in the Netherlands. European Journal of Public Health 29(3): 463–467.
Bolognani, M. and Erdal, M.B. (2017). Return imaginaries and political climate: Comparing thinking about return mobilities among Pakistani origin migrants and descendants in Norway and the UK. Journal of International Migration and Integration 18(1): 353–367.
Borkowska, M., Nazroo, J., Finney, N., and Harrison, J. (2023). Ethnic identities. In: Finney, N., Nazroo, J., Bécares, L., Kapadia, D., and Shlomo, N. (eds.). Racism and ethnic inequality in a time of crisis: Findings from the Evidence for Equality National Survey. Bristol: Policy Press: 30–53.
Brochmann, G. and Kjeldstadli, K. (2008). A History of immigration: The case of Norway 900–2000. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.
Castles, S. (1986). The guest-worker in Western Europe - an obituary. International Migration Review 20(4): 761–778.
Charsley, K., Storer-Church, B., Benson, M., and Van Hear, N. (2012). Marriage-related migration to the UK. International Migration Review 46(4): 861–890.
Chiswick, B.R., Lee, Y.L., and Miller, P.W. (2008). Immigrant selection systems and immigrant health. Contemporary Economic Policy 26(4): 555–578.
Constant, A.F. (2017). The healthy immigrant paradox and health convergence. CESifo DICE Report 15(3): 20–25.
Delaney, L., Fernihough, A., and Smith, J.P. (2013). Exporting poor health: The Irish in England. Demography 50(6): 2013–2035.
Eikemo, T., Bambra, C., Judge, K., and Ringdal, K. (2008). Welfare state regimes and differences in self-perceived health in Europe: A multilevel analysis. Social Science and Medicine 66(11): 2281–2295.
Espelt, A., Borrell, C., Rodríguez-Sanz, M., Muntaner, C., Pasarín, M.I., Benach, J., Schaap, M., Kunst, A.E., and Navarro, V. (2008). Inequalities in health by social class dimensions in European countries of different political traditions. International Journal of Epidemiology 37(5): 1095–1105.
Esping-Andersen, G. (1990). The three political economies of the welfare state. International Journal of Sociology 20(3): 92–123.
Ferrera, M. (1996). The ‘southern model’ of welfare in social Europe. Journal of European Social Policy 6(1): 17–37.
Ferretti, F. (2015). Unhealthy behaviours: An international comparison. PLOS ONE 10(10): e0141834.
Franke, S. and Kulu, H. (2018). Cause-specific mortality by partnership status: Simultaneous analysis using longitudinal data from England and Wales. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 72(9): 838–844.
Friberg, J.H. (2016). New patterns of labour migration from Central and Eastern Europe and its impact on labour markets and institutions in Norway: Reviewing the evidence. In: Dalvik, J.E. and Eldring, L. (eds.). Labour mobility in the enlarged single European market. Leeds: Emerald Group Publishing Limited: 19–43.
Friberg, J.H. and Midtbøen, A.H. (2018). Ethnicity as skill: immigrant employment hierarchies in Norwegian low-wage labour markets. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 44(9): 1463–1478.
Grytten, J., Skau, I., and Sørensen, R. (2020). Who dies early? Education, mortality and causes of death in Norway. Social Science and Medicine 245(112601): 112601.
Guillot, M., Khlat, M., Elo, I., Solignac, M., and Wallace, M. (2018). Understanding age variations in the migrant mortality advantage: An international comparative perspective. PLOS ONE 13(6): 0199669.
Harding, S. (2003). Mortality of migrants from the Indian Subcontinent to England and Wales: Effect of duration of residence. Epidemiology 14(3): 287–292.
Harding, S. (1998). The incidence of cancers among second-generation Irish living in England and Wales. British Journal of Cancer 78(7): 958–961.
Harding, S. and Balarajan, R. (2000). Limiting long-term illness among Black Caribbeans, Black Africans, Indians, Pakistanis, Bangladeshis and Chinese born in the UK. Ethnicity and Health 5(1): 41–46.
Harding, S. and Balarajan, R. (2001). Mortality of third generation Irish people living in England and Wales: Longitudinal study. BMJ 322(7284): 466–467.
Hattersley, L. and Creeser, R. (1995). The Longitudinal Study, 1971–1991: History, organisation and quality of data. LS Series.
Hermansen, A.S., Hundebo, P.O., and Birkelund, G.E. (2022). Spatial assimilation at a halt? Intergenerational persistence in neighborhood contexts among immigrant minorities in Norway. International Migration Review 56(4): 1069–1106.
Honkaniemi, H., Bacchus-Hertzman, J., Fritzell, J., and Rostila, M. (2017). Mortality by country of birth in the Nordic countries – A systematic review of the literature. BMC Public Health 17(1): 1–12.
Hurrelmann, K., Rathmann, K., and Richter, M. (2011). Health inequalities and welfare state regimes. A research note. Journal of Public Health 19(1): 3–13.
Ibrahim, Y. and Howarth, A. (2018). Review of humanitarian refuge in the United Kingdom: Sanctuary, asylum, and the refugee crisis. Politics and Policy 46(3): 348–391.
Ikram, U.Z., Mackenbach, J.P., Harding, S., Rey, G., Bhopal, R., Regidor, E., Rosato, M., Juel, K., Stronks, K., and Kunst, A.E. (2016). All-cause and cause-specific mortality of different migrant populations in Europe. European Journal of Epidemiology 31(7): 655–665.
Ikram, U.Z., Malmusi, D., Juel, K., Rey, G., and Kunst, A.E. (2015). Association between integration policies and immigrants’ mortality: An explorative study across three European countries. PLoS ONE 10(6): 0129916.
Isaksen, J.V. (2020). The framing of immigration and integration in Sweden and Norway: A comparative study of official government reports. Nordic Journal of Migration Research 10(1): 106–124.
Juárez, S.P. and Rostila, M. (2017). Non-European migrants often have similar or better health than natives. Sociologisk Forskning 54(4): 323–327.
Kulu, H. and Hannemann, T. (2019). Mixed marriage among immigrants and their descendants in the United Kingdom: Analysis of longitudinal data with missing information. Population Studies 73(2): 179–196.
Larsen, E.N. and Di Stasio, V. (2021). Pakistani in the UK and Norway: Different contexts, similar disadvantage. Results from a comparative field experiment on hiring discrimination. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 47(6): 1201–1221.
Lee, E.T. and Wang, J.W. (2013). Statistical methods for survival data analysis. Wiley.
Loi, S. and Hale, J.M. (2019). Migrant health convergence and the role of material deprivation. Demographic Research 40(32): 933–962.
Mackenbach, J.P. (2019). Health inequalities in Europe. How does Norway compare? Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 47(6): 666–671.
Magnusson Turner, L. and Wessel, T. (2013). Upwards, outwards and westwards: relocation of ethnic minority groups in the Oslo region. Geografiska Annaler, Series B: Human Geography 95(1): 1–16.
Marshall, L., Finch, D., Cairncross, L., and Bibby, J. (2019). Mortality and life expectancy trends in the UK: Stalling progress. London: The Health Foundation.
Midtbøen, A.H. (2016). Discrimination of the second generation: Evidence from a field experiment in Norway. Journal of International Migration and Integration 17(1): 253–272.
Midtbøen, A.H. (2015). The context of employment discrimination: Interpreting the findings of a field experiment. British Journal of Sociology 66(1): 193–214.
Midtbøen, A.H. (2014). The invisible second generation? Statistical discrimination and immigrant stereotypes in employment processes in Norway. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 40(10): 1657–1675.
Monti, A., Drefahl, S., Mussino, E., and Härkönen, J. (2020). Over-coverage in population registers leads to bias in demographic estimates. Population Studies 74(3): 451–469.
Nazroo, J. (2003). The structuring of ethnic inequalities in health: Economic position, racial discrimination, and racism. American Journal of Public Health 93(2): 277–284.
Nelson, K. and Fritzell, J. (2014). Welfare states and population health: The role of minimum income benefits for mortality. Social Science and Medicine 112: 63–71.
Office for National Statistics (2019). ONS SRS Metadata Catalogue, dataset, ONS Longitudinal Study –England and Wales [electronic resource].
Office for National Statistics (2020). Population of the UK by Country of Birth and Nationality. Newport: ONS.
Paradies, Y., Ben, J., Denson, N., Elias, A., Priest, N., Pieterse, A., Gupta, A., Kelaher, M., and Gee, G. (2015). Racism as a determinant of health: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLOS ONE 10(9): 1–48.
Parry, G., Van Cleemput, P., Peters, J., Walters, S., Thomas, K., and Cooper, C. (2007). Health status of Gypsies and Travellers in England. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 61(3): 198–204.
Parveen, S. (2020). Norwegian asylum policy and response to the 2015 refugee crisis. International Studies 57(4): 391–406.
Peach, C. (2006). South Asian migration and settlement in Great Britain, 1951–2001. Contemporary South Asia 15(2): 133–146.
Power, C., Hyppönen, E., and Smith, G.D. (2005). Socioeconomic position in childhood and early adult life and risk of mortality: A prospective study of the mothers of the 1958 British birth cohort. American Journal of Public Health 95(8): 1396–1402.
Price, L. (2014). Immigrants and apprentices: Solutions to the post-war labour shortage in the West Yorkshire wool textile industry, 1945–1980. Textile History 45(1): 32–48.
Qian, Z. and Lichter, D.T. (2007). Social boundaries and marital assimilation: Interpreting trends in racial and ethnic intermarriage. American Sociological Review 72(1): 68–94.
Rabanal, K.S., Lindman, A.S., Selmer, R.M., and Aamodt, G. (2013). Ethnic differences in risk factors and total risk of cardiovascular disease based on the Norwegian CONOR study. European Journal of Preventive Cardiology 20(6): 1013–1021.
Razum, O. (2006). Commentary: Of salmon and time travellers – Musing on the mystery of migrant mortality. International Journal of Epidemiology 35(4): 919–921.
Razum, O. (2008). Migrant mortality, healthy migrant effect. In: Kirch, W. (ed.). Encyclopedia of public health. Dordrecht: Springer: 933–935.
Razum, O. and Twardella, D. (2002). Viewpoint: Time travel with Oliver Twist – Towards an explanation for a paradoxically low mortality among recent immigrants. Tropical Medicine and International Health 7(1): 4–10.
Roura, M. (2017). Unravelling migrants’ health paradoxes: A transdisciplinary research agenda. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 71(9): 870–873.
Saunes, I.S. (2020). The Norwegian health care system. In: Tikkanen, R., Osborn, R., Mossialos, E., Djordjevic, A., and Wharton, G. (eds.). International profiles of health care systems. Bristol: Bristol University Press: 159–168.
Shankley, W. and Finney, N. (2020). Ethnic minorities and housing in Britain. In: Byrne, B., Alexander, C., Khan, O., Nazroo, J., and Shankley, W. (eds.). Ethnicity, race and inequality in the UK: State of the Nation. Bristol: Bristol University Press: 149–166.
Shor, E. and Roelfs, D. (2021). A global meta-analysis of the immigrant mortality advantage. International Migration Review 55(4): 999–1028.
Simpson, L., Warren, J., and Jivraj, S. (2015). Do people change their ethnicity over time? In: Jivraj, S. and Simpson, L. (eds.). Ethnic identity and inequalities in Britain: The dynamics of diversity. Bristol: Bristol University Press: 79–92.
Spallek, J., Arnold, M., Razum, O., Juel, K., Rey, G., Deboosere, P., Mackenbach, J.P., and Kunst, A.E. (2012). Cancer mortality patterns among Turkish immigrants in four European countries and in Turkey. European Journal of Epidemiology 27(12): 915–921.
Statistics Norway (2023). Educational attainment of the population.
Statistics Norway (2023). Immigrants and Norwegian-born to immigrant parents.
Syed, H.R., Dalgard, O.S., Hussain, A., Dalen, I., Claussen, B., and Ahlberg, N.L. (2006). Inequalities in health: A comparative study between ethnic Norwegians and Pakistanis in Oslo, Norway. International Journal for Equity in Health 5: 1–9.
Syse, A., Dzamarija, M.T., Kumar, B., and Diaz, E. (2018). An observational study of immigrant mortality differences in Norway by reason for migration, length of stay and characteristics of sending countries. BMC Public Health 18(508).
Syse, A., Strand, B.H., Naess, O., Steingrímsdóttir, Ó.A., and Kumar, B. (2016). Differences in all-cause mortality: A comparison between immigrants and the host population in Norway 1990–2012. Demographic Research 34(22): 615–656.
Thorlby, R. (2020). The English health care systems. In: Tikkanen, R., Osborn, R., Mossialos, E., Djordjecvic, A., and Wharton, G. (eds.). International profiles of health care systems. New York: The Commonwealth Fund: 59–70.
Vanthomme, K. and Vandenheede, H. (2019). Migrant mortality differences in the 2000s in Belgium: Interaction with gender and the role of socioeconomic position. International Journal for Equity in Health 18(1).
Vanthomme, K. and Vandenheede, H. (2019). Trends in Belgian cause-specific mortality by migrant origin between the 1990s and the 2000s. BMC Public Health 19(410).
Wallace, M. (2016). Adult mortality among the descendants of immigrants in England and Wales: Does a migrant mortality advantage persist beyond the first generation? Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 42(9): 1558–1577.
Wallace, M. (2022). Mortality advantage reversed: The causes of death driving all-cause mortality differentials between immigrants, the descendants of immigrants and ancestral natives in Sweden, 1997–2016. European Journal of Population 38(5): 1213–1241.
Wallace, M. and Darlington‐Pollock, F. (2022). Poor health, low mortality? Paradox found among immigrants in England and Wales. Population, Space and Place 28(3): 1–15.
Wallace, M., Franklin, C., and Harrison, J. (2025). Long lives, poor health? A comprehensive review of the evidence among international migrants. British Medical Bulletin 156(1): 014.
Wallace, M., Hiam, L., and Aldridge, R.W. (2023). Elevated mortality among the second-generation (children of migrants) in Europe: What is going wrong? A review. British Medical Bulletin 148(1): 5–21.
Wallace, M. and Kulu, H. (2018). Can the salmon bias effect explain the migrant mortality advantage in England and Wales? Population, Space and Place 24(8).
Wallace, M. and Kulu, H. (2014). Low immigrant mortality in England and Wales: A data artefact? Social Science and Medicine 120: 100–109.
Wallace, M. and Kulu, H. (2015). Mortality among immigrants in England and Wales by major causes of death, 1971–2012: A longitudinal analysis of register-based data. Social Science and Medicine 147: 209–221.
Wallace, M., Thomas, M.J., Aburto, J.M., Jørring Pallesen, A.V., Mortensen, L.H., Syse, A., and Drefahl, S. (2022). Immigration, mortality, and national life expectancy in the Nordic region, 1990–2019. SSM – Population Health 19(101177).
Wallace, M. and Wilson, B. (2022). Age variations and population over-coverage: Is low mortality among migrants merely a data artefact? Population Studies 76(1): 81–98.
Wallace, M. and Wilson, B. (2019). Migrant mortality advantage versus origin and the selection hypothesis. Population and Development Review 45(4): 767–794.
Wang, S. and Li, S. (2019). Exploring generational differences of British ethnic minorities in smoking behavior, frequency of alcohol consumption, and dietary style. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 16(12).
Wild, S.H., Fischbacher, C., Brock, A., Griffiths, C., and Bhopal, R. (2007). Mortality from all causes and circulatory disease by country of birth in England and Wales 2001–2003. Journal of Public Health 29(2): 191–198.