Volume 24 - Article 14 | Pages 313–344  

Family size and intergenerational social mobility during the fertility transition: Evidence of resource dilution from the city of Antwerp in nineteenth century Belgium

By Jan Van Bavel, Sarah Moreels, Bart Van de Putte, Koen Matthijs

This article is part of the Special Collection 10 „Social Mobility and Demographic Behaviour: A Long-Term Perspective“

Abstract

It has been argued in sociology, economics, and evolutionary anthropology that family size limitation enhances the intergenerational upward mobility chances in modernized societies. If parents have a large flock, family resources get diluted and intergenerational mobility is bound to head downwards. Yet, the empirical record supporting this resource dilution hypothesis is limited. This article investigates the empirical association between family size limitation and intergenerational mobility in an urban, late nineteenth century population in Western Europe. It uses life course data from the Belgian city of Antwerp between 1846 and 1920. Findings are consistent with the resource dilution hypothesis: after controlling for confounding factors, people with many children were more likely to end up in the lower classes. Yet, family size limitation was effective as a defensive rather than an offensive strategy: it prevented the next generation from going down rather than helping them to climb up the social ladder. Also, family size appears to have been particularly relevant for the middle classes. Implications for demographic transition theory are discussed.

Author’s Affiliation

• Jan Van Bavel - Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium EMAIL
• Sarah Moreels - Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium EMAIL
• Bart Van de Putte - Ghent University, Belgium EMAIL
• Koen Matthijs - Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Left behind single in the partnering market? Entry into cohabiting unions by women and men with low educational attainment across regions of Europe, cohorts 1960 to 1985
Volume 51 - Article 43

Climate change and fertility desires: An experimental study among university students in Belgium and Italy
Volume 51 - Article 2

Partner selection patterns in transition: The case of Turkish and Moroccan minorities in Belgium
Volume 45 - Article 34

Gender differences and similarities in the educational gradient in fertility: The role of earnings potential and gender composition in study disciplines
Volume 39 - Article 13

Stepfather or biological father? Education-specific pathways of postdivorce fatherhood
Volume 37 - Article 51

Fertility among descendants of immigrants in Belgium: The role of the partner
Volume 36 - Article 60

Traditional and modern cohabitation in Latin America: A comparative typology
Volume 32 - Article 32

Post-divorce family trajectories of men and women in Flanders
Volume 32 - Article 31

Rivalry, solidarity, and longevity among siblings: A life course approach to the impact of sibship composition and birth order on later life mortality risk, Antwerp (1846-1920)
Volume 31 - Article 38

The mid-twentieth century Baby Boom and the changing educational gradient in Belgian cohort fertility
Volume 30 - Article 33

Estimating the contribution of mothers of foreign origin to total fertility: The recent recovery of period fertility in the Belgian region of Flanders
Volume 30 - Article 12

Characteristics of joint physical custody families in Flanders
Volume 28 - Article 29

Post-divorce custody arrangements and binuclear family structures of Flemish adolescents
Volume 28 - Article 15

Regional family cultures and child care by grandparents in Europe
Volume 27 - Article 4

Social mobility and demographic behaviour: Long term perspectives
Volume 26 - Article 8

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Early unintended childbearing and unsecured debt in the United States
Volume 53 - Article 27    | Keywords: demography, fertility, gender, life course, mothers

Neighbors’ social attitudes predict variations in live births among the Amish of Holmes County, Ohio, United States
Volume 53 - Article 25    | Keywords: Amish, diffusion, fertility, household, proximity, religion, spatial analysis

Analysing migrant fertility using machine learning techniques: An application of random survival forest to longitudinal data from France
Volume 53 - Article 21    | Keywords: fertility, immigrants, machine learning, random survival forest, survival analysis

The partnership, fertility, and employment trajectories of immigrants in the United Kingdom: An intersectional life course approach using three-channel sequence analysis
Volume 53 - Article 10    | Keywords: employment, fertility, immigrants, multi-channel sequence analysis, partnership, United Kingdom

Where do we go from here? Partnership-parenthood trajectories of cohabitation as first union during young adulthood in the United States
Volume 53 - Article 9    | Keywords: cohabitation, family inequality, fertility, marriage, race/ethnicity, transition to adulthood, union formation, United States of America