Volume 34 - Article 2 | Pages 39–62  

Does selection of mortality model make a difference in projecting population ageing?

By Sergei Scherbov, Dalkhat Ediev

Abstract

Background: In low mortality countries, assessing future ageing depends to a large extent on scenarios of future mortality reduction at old age. Often in population projections mortality reduction is implemented via life expectancy increases that do not specify mortality change at specific age groups. The selection of models that translate life expectancy into age-specific mortality rates may be of great importance for projecting the older age groups of future populations and indicators of ageing.

Objective: We quantify how the selection of mortality models, assuming similar life expectancy scenarios, affects projected indices of population ageing.

Methods: Using the cohort-component method, we project the populations of Italy, Japan, Russia, Sweden, and the USA. For each country, the given scenario of life expectancy at birth is translated into age-specific death rates by applying four alternative mortality models (variants of extrapolations of the log-mortality rates, the Brass relational model, and the Bongaarts shifting model). The models are contrasted according to their produced future age-specific mortality rates, population age composition, life expectancy at age 65, age at remaining life expectancy 15 years, and conventional and prospective old-age dependency ratios.

Conclusions: We show strong differences between the alternative mortality models in terms of mortality age pattern and ageing indicators. Researchers of population ageing should be as careful about their choice of model of age patterns of future mortality as about scenarios of future life expectancy. The simultaneous extrapolation of age-specific death rates may be a better alternative to projecting life expectancy first and then deriving the age patterns of mortality in the second step.

Author's Affiliation

• Sergei Scherbov - International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA), Austria EMAIL
• Dalkhat Ediev - International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA), Austria EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Significance of life table estimates for small populations: Simulation-based study of estimation errors
Volume 24 - Article 22

How many old people have ever lived?
Volume 36 - Article 54

Differences by union status in health and mortality at older ages: Results for 16 European countries
Volume 35 - Article 19

Quantifying policy tradeoffs to support aging populations
Volume 30 - Article 20

Very long range global population scenarios to 2300 and the implications of sustained low fertility
Volume 28 - Article 39

A new perspective on population aging
Volume 16 - Article 2

Marriage in Russia: a reconstruction
Volume 10 - Article 2

On Monotonic Convergence To Stability
Volume 8 - Article 2

Period Fertility in Russia since 1930: an application of the Coale-Trussell fertility model
Volume 6 - Article 16

Application of the Demographic Potential Concept to Understanding the Russian Population History and Prospects: 1897-2100
Volume 4 - Article 9

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Age reporting for the oldest old in the Brazilian COVID-19 vaccination database: What can we learn from it?
Volume 48 - Article 28    | Keywords: age misreporting, Brazil, COVID-19, mortality crossover, oldest old, population aging, vaccinations

Migration and demographic disparities in macro-regions of the European Union, a view to 2060
Volume 45 - Article 44    | Keywords: migration, population projections

Projecting the sexual minority population: Methods, data, and illustrative projections for Australia
Volume 45 - Article 12    | Keywords: Australia, LGBTQ, population projections, sexual minority

Population aging caused by a rise in the sex ratio at birth
Volume 43 - Article 32    | Keywords: models, population aging, sex ratio at birth, stable population

A framework for the prospective analysis of ethno-cultural super-diversity
Volume 41 - Article 11    | Keywords: diversity, immigration, microsimulation, population projections