Volume 32 - Article 33 | Pages 915–948  

Smoothing internal migration age profiles for comparative research

By Aude Bernard, Martin Bell

Abstract

Background: Age patterns are a key dimension to compare migration between countries and over time. Comparative metrics can be reliably computed only if data capture the underlying age distribution of migration. Model schedules, the prevailing smoothing method, fit a composite exponential function, but are sensitive to function selection and initial parameter setting. Although non-parametric alternatives exist, their performance is yet to be established.

Objective: We compare cubic splines and kernel regressions against model schedules by assessing which method provides an accurate representation of the age profile and best performs on metrics for comparing aggregate age patterns.

Methods: We use full population microdata for Chile to perform 1,000 Monte-Carlo simulations for nine sample sizes and two spatial scales. We use residual and graphic analysis to assess model performance on the age and intensity at which migration peaks and the evolution of migration age patterns.

Results: Model schedules generate a better fit when (1) the expected distribution of the age profile is known a priori, (2) the pre-determined shape of the model schedule adequately describes the true age distribution, and (3) the component curves and initial parameter values can be correctly set. When any of these conditions is not met, kernel regressions and cubic splines offer more reliable alternatives.

Conclusions: Smoothing models should be selected according to research aims, age profile characteristics, and sample size. Kernel regressions and cubic splines enable a precise representation of aggregate migration age profiles for most sample sizes, without requiring parameter setting or imposing a pre-determined distribution, and therefore facilitate objective comparison.

Author's Affiliation

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Educational selectivity of internal migrants: A global assessment
Volume 39 - Article 29

Educational selectivity of native and foreign-born internal migrants in Europe
Volume 47 - Article 34

Internal migration and the de-standardization of the life course: A sequence analysis of reasons for migrating
Volume 46 - Article 12

Distinguishing tempo and ageing effects in migration
Volume 40 - Article 44

Australia's uncertain demographic future
Volume 11 - Article 8

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Aligning household decision-making with work and education: A comparative analysis of women’s empowerment
Volume 48 - Article 19    | Keywords: autonomy, cross-national comparison, decision-making, developing countries, development, gender, gender inequalities, latent class analysis, women empowerment

Solo living in the process of transitioning to adulthood in Europe: The role of socioeconomic background
Volume 48 - Article 3    | Keywords: cross-national comparison, Europe, leaving home, life course, living alone, trajectories, transition to adulthood

Household structure across childhood in four lower- and middle-income countries
Volume 47 - Article 6    | Keywords: children, cross-national comparison, developing countries, household structure, sequence analysis

Parental socioeconomic status and the timing of first marriage: What is the role of unmarried cohabitation? Results from a cross-national comparison
Volume 45 - Article 15    | Keywords: cross-national comparison, first marriages, parental status, socioeconomic status, unmarried cohabitation

Exploring the concept of intensive parenting in a three-country study
Volume 44 - Article 13    | Keywords: cross-national comparison, fertility, intensive parenting, norms hypothesis