Volume 41 - Article 30 | Pages 873–912  

Changing gender relations, declining fertility? An analysis of childbearing trajectories in 19th-century Netherlands

By Hilde Bras, Reto Schumacher


Background: A long-standing and still unresolved debate has developed on whether the historical fertility transition was caused by ‘spacing’ (increasing the time between births) or by stopping (terminating childbearing at younger ages). Moreover, there is little consensus about the relative importance of gender relations in effecting reproductive change.

Objective: First, we wish to shed new light on the stopping versus spacing debate by applying a sequence analysis approach, allowing us to describe changes in complete childbearing trajectories. Second, we want to understand the association between gender relations, among other factors, and reproductive trajectories during the historical fertility decline.

Methods: We use longitudinal data from GENLIAS, a dataset constructed from linked civil registers of the province of Zeeland, the Netherlands, covering the period 1811‒1911. We employ cluster and sequence analysis to identify different types of childbearing trajectories and logistic regression to estimate their correlates.

Results: We identified five often-experienced trajectories: two high-fertility traditional trajectories (differing in the length of the reproductive phase), a ‘Stoppers’ trajectory, a ‘Late Starters’ trajectory, and an ‘Almost Childless’ trajectory. Our results show that stopping was the way through which couples controlled their fertility during the early phase of the historical fertility transition in Zeeland, the Netherlands. Although couples with more egalitarian relationships had a higher likelihood to follow a Stoppers trajectory rather than the highest-fertility trajectory, stopping was most clearly linked to birth cohort and social class.

Contribution: Our paper extends the literature on the process of the historical fertility decline and its determinants via a detailed empirical examination of childbearing trajectories and the conditions under which these trajectories took place. With our sequence analysis approach we add both substantively and methodologically to long-standing debates.

Author's Affiliation

  • Hilde Bras - Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, the Netherlands EMAIL
  • Reto Schumacher - Statistique Vaud (Service Cantonal de Recherche et d'Informations Statistiques [SCRIS]), Switzerland EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

The age difference between spouses and reproduction in 19th century Sweden
Volume 41 - Article 37

Structural and diffusion effects in the Dutch fertility transition, 1870-1940
Volume 30 - Article 5

Gender differences in social mortality differentials in Switzerland (1990-2005)
Volume 25 - Article 8

Sibship size and status attainment across contexts: Evidence from the Netherlands, 1840-1925
Volume 23 - Article 4

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Describing the Dutch Social Networks and Fertility Study and how to process it
Volume 49 - Article 19    | Keywords: fertility, Netherlands, personal networks, social influence

Changing mind, changing plans? Instability of individual gender attitudes and postponement of marriage in Germany
Volume 47 - Article 25    | Keywords: childbearing, family formation, gender attitudes, marriage, multidimensional attitudes

Disentangling the Swedish fertility decline of the 2010s
Volume 47 - Article 12    | Keywords: childbearing, fertility, fertility decline, fertility trends, Sweden

Exploring the mortality advantage of Jewish neighbourhoods in mid-19th century Amsterdam
Volume 46 - Article 25    | Keywords: 19th century, Amsterdam, cause-specific mortality, historical demography, inequality, Jewish neighborhoods

The contribution of assisted reproductive technology to fertility rates and parity transition: An analysis of Australian data
Volume 45 - Article 35    | Keywords: childbearing, childlessness, first birth, reproduction, total fertility rate (TFR)