Volume 49 - Article 10 | Pages 219–248
Use of standard verbal autopsies to improve the mortality data capacity of civil registration and vital statistics systems in low- and middle-income countries: Analysis of key issues
By Nnamdi Maduekwe, Olufunmilayo Banjo, Mike O. Sangodapo, Aisha Abdulazeez
References
Akakpo, P.K. (2020). Community causes of death in the central region of Ghana, the missing piece in mortality data. Hindawi Advances in Public Health 2020(2714616).
Alabi, O., Doctor, H.V., Jumare, A., Sahabi, N., Abdulwahab, A., Findley, S.E., and Abubakar, S.D. (2014). Health and demographic surveillance system profile: The Nahuche Health and Demographic Surveillance System, Northern Nigeria (Nahuche HDSS). International Journal of Epidemiology 43(6): 1770–1780.
APAI-CRVS (2017). Africa Programme for Accelerated Improvement of Civil Registration and Vital Statistics: Costed strategic plan 2017–2021. Paper presented at the Fourth Conference of African Ministers Responsible for Civil Registration, Nouakchott, Mauritania, 4‒8 December 2017.
Azad, A.K. (2013). Report of the comprehensive assessment and Strategic Action Plan on CRVS (Civil Registration and Vital Statistics) in Bangladesh.
Boyce, R.M. and Reyes, R. (2020). Implementing and scaling verbal autopsies: Into the unknown. BMC Medicine 18(53).
Bratschi, M.W., Thomas, J.S., Leitao, J., Mswia, R., and Nichols, E.K. (2021). Implementing verbal autopsy in the CRVS system, strengthening civil registration and vital statistics (CRVS) systems, Guide 4.
CDC (2021). Community based verbal autopsy linked to Kenya’s Civil Registration and Vital Statistics system 2016.
Chan, K.S., Roberts, E., McCleary, R., Buttorff, C., and Gaskin, D.J. (2014). Community characteristics and mortality: The relative strength of association of different community characteristics. American Journal of Public Health 104(9): 1751–1758.
Chandramohan, D. (2011). Validation and validity of verbal autopsy procedures. Population Health Metrics 9(22).
Cobos Muñoz, D., Abouzahr, C., and Savigny, D. (2018). The ‘Ten CRVS Milestones’ framework for understanding Civil Registration and Vital Statistics systems. BMJ Glob Health 25(3): e000673.
Cobos Muñoz, D., Monzon, L.L., Dayo, C., Renggli, S., and deSavigny, D. (2018). Developing a verbal autopsy costing and budgeting tool. CRVS analyses and evaluations 2018. Melbourne: Bloomberg Philanthropies Data for Health Initiative, Civil Registration and Vital Statistics Improvement, University of Melbourne.
de Savigny, D., Renggli, S., Cobos, D., Collinson, M., and Sankoh, O. (2018). Maximizing Synergies between Health Observatories and CRVS: Guidance for INDEPTH HDSS Sites and CRVS Stakeholders 2018. INDEPTH Network and the Bloomberg Data for Health Initiative.
de Savigny, D., Riley, I., Chandramohan, D., Odhiambo, F., Nichols, E., Notzon, S., AbouZahr, C., Mitra, R., Cobos Muñoz, D., Firth, S., Maire, N., Sankoh, O., Bronson, G., Setel, P., Byass, P., Jakob, R., Boerma, T., and Lopez, A.D. (2017). Integrating community-based verbal autopsy into civil registration and vital statistics (CRVS): System-level considerations. Global Health Action .
DNRPC Zambia (2014). National Strategic Action Plan for Reforming and Improving Civil Registration and Vital Statistics. Lusaka: DNRPC Zambia.
Fottrell, E.F. (2011). Advances in verbal autopsy: Pragmatic optimism or optimistic theory? Advances in verbal autopsy: pragmatic optimism or optimistic theory? Population Health Metrics 9(24).
Fottrell, E.F. (2008). Dying to count: mortality surveillance methods in resource-poor settings. Umeå University.
Garba, J.A. and Umar, S. (2013). Aetiology of maternal mortality using verbal autopsy at Sokoto, North-Western Nigeria. African Journal of Primary Health Care and Family Medicine 5(1): 442.
GSMA (2021). Birth registration in Tanzania: Tigo’s support of the new mobile birth registration system.
Haider, M.M., Alam, N., Ibn Bashar, M., and Helleringer, S. (2021). Adult death registration in Matlab, rural Bangladesh: Completeness, correlates, and obstacles. Genus 77(13).
Hazard, R.H., Buddhika, M.P.K., Hart, J.D., Chowdhury, H.R., Firth, S., Joshi, R., Avelino, F., Segarra, A., Sarmiento, D.C., Azad, A.K., Ashrafi, S.A.A., Sandar Bo, K., Kwa, V., and Lopez, A.D. (2020). Automated verbal autopsy: from research to routine use in civil registration and vital statistics systems. BMC Medicine 18(60).
Joshi, R., Praveen, D., Jan, S., Raju, K., Maulik, P., Jha, V., and Lopez, A.D. (2015). How much does a verbal autopsy based mortality surveillance system cost in rural India? PLoS ONE 10(5): e0126410.
Kavanagh, M.M., Katz, I.T., and Holmes, C.B. (2005). Reckoning with mortality: Global health, HIV, and the politics of data. Lancet 396(10246): 288–290.
Kavuma, S.F. (2015). Lessons learned from local initiatives supporting sustainable civil registration and vital statistics (CRVS) systems in Africa. Paper presented at the IUSSP Side meeting at the 7th African Population Conference, Johannesburg, 2015.
Khan, Z. and Mursalin, S.M. (2020). Review of availability, registration and quality of hospital based death statistics and determining mortality patterns by cause of death, 2020. Paper presented at the Asia–Pacific Statistics Week: A decade of action for the 2030 Agenda: Statistics that leaves no one and nowhere behind .
Koffi, A.K., Kalter, H.D., Loveth, E.N., Quinley, J., Monehin, J., and Black, R.E. (2017). Beyond causes of death: The social determinants of mortality among children aged 1‒59 months in Nigeria from 2009 to 2013. PLoS ONE 12(5): e0177025.
Koffi, A.K., Maina, A., Yaroh, A.G., Habi, O., Bensaïd, K., and Kalter, H.D. (2016). Social determinants of child mortality in Niger: Results from the 2012 National Verbal and Social Autopsy Study. Journal of Global Health 6(1): 010603.
Krishnan, A., Gupta, V., Nongkynrih, B., Kumar, R., Kaur, R., Malhotra, S., Salve, H.R., Narayan, V., Gupta, A., and MINErVA Network (2020). Mortality in India established through verbal autopsies (MINErVA): Strengthening national mortality surveillance system in India. Journal of Global Health 10(2): 020431.
Laney, R.C., Barroca, L., Jackson, M., and Nuseibeh, B.A. (2004). Composing requirements using problem frames. In: Proceedings. 12th IEEE International Requirements Engineering Conference, 2004. Kyoto, Japan: 122‒131.
Lasisi, A.O., Esan, O., Abiona, T.A., and Gureje, O. (2018). Causes and risks of death using verbal autopsy in the Ibadan Study of Ageing. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Health 118.
Lawal, S. (2019). VASA necessary for behavioural change, national planning ‒ Ehanire: A report in The Vanguard Newspaper. Vanguard Newspaper.
Lepang, N.C. (2015). Lessons learnt from local initiatives supporting sustainable civil registration and vital statistics in Africa: The case of Botswana. Paper presented at the IUSSP Side meeting at the 7th African Population Conference, Johannesburg, 2015.
Lopez, A.D., McLaughlin, D., and Richards, N. (2020). Reducing ignorance about who dies of what: Research and innovation to strengthen CRVS systems. BMC Medicine 18(58).
Maduekwe, N.I. (2011). The application of geographic information systems to health and demographic surveillance systems: A case study of Oriade HDSS. Ile-Ife, Nigeria, Unpublished PGD Project submitted to the regional Center for Training in Aerospace Survey (RECTAS).
Maduekwe, N.I., Banjo, O.O., and Anyabolu, H. (2018). Understanding civil registration and vital statistics as a component of the sustainable development goals data ecosystem in Nigeria. Ife Social Sciences Review 2018(Special Issue on Institutional framework for the Practise of The SDGs): 450‒460 (2018(Special Issue on Institutional framework for the Practise of The SDGs): 450‒460.).
Maduekwe, N.I., Banjo, O.O., and Sangodapo, M.O. (2018). Data for the sustainable development goals: Metrics for evaluating civil registration and vital statistics systems data relevance and production capacity, illustrations with Nigeria. Social Indicators Research 140(1): 101–124.
Maduekwe, N.I., Banjo, O.O., and Sangodapo, M.O. (2017). The Nigerian civil registration and vital statistics system: Contexts, institutions, operation. Social Indicators Research 134(2): 651–674.
Makinde, O.A., Odimegwu, C.O., Udoh, M.O., Adedini, S.A., Akinyemi, J.O., Atobatele, A., Fadeyibi, O., Abdulaziz Sule, F., Babalola, S., and Orobaton, N. (2020). Death registration in Nigeria: A systematic literature review of its performance and challenges. Global Health Action 13(1).
McLean, E.M., Chihana, M., Mzembe, T., Koole, O., Kachiwanda, L., Glynn, J.R., Zaba, B., Nyirenda, M., and Crampin, A.C. (2016). Reliability of reporting of HIV status and antiretroviral therapy usage during verbal autopsies: A large prospective study in rural Malawi. Global Health Action 9(1): 31084.
Mills, S.L., Abouzahr, C., Kim, J., Bahie, M.R., and Sarpong, D. (2017). Civil Registration and Vital Statistics (CRVS) for monitoring the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Paper presented at the eLearning course on Civil Registration and Vital Statistics Systems, Washington, D.C, 2017.
Mudenda, S.S., Kamocha, S., Mswia, R., Conkling, M., Sikanyiti, P., Potter, D., Mayaka, WC, and Marx, M.A. (2011). Feasibility of using a World Health Organization standard methodology for Sample Vital Registration with Verbal Autopsy (SAVVY) to report leading causes of death in Zambia: results of a pilot in four provinces. Population Health Metrics 9(40).
Murray, C.J.L., Lopez, A.D., Shibuya, K., and Lozano, R. (2011). Verbal autopsy: Advancing science, facilitating application. Population Health Metrics 9(18).
National Population Commission (2004). Manual on registration of births and deaths. Abuja: National Population Commission.
Nichols, E.K., Byass, P., Chandramohan, D., Clark, S.J., Flaxman, A.D., Jakob, R., Leitao, J., Maire, N., Rao, C., Riley, I., and Setel, P.W. (2018). The WHO 2016 verbal autopsy instrument: An international standard suitable for automated analysis by Inter VA. SilicoVA, and Tariff 2.0. PLoS Medicine 15(1): e1002486.
NISR - National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda (2021). Rwanda Vital Statistics Report 2020. Rwanda Vital Statistics Report.
Queiroz, B.L., Gonzaga, M.R., Vasconcelos, A.M.N., Lopes, B.T., and Abreu, D.M.X. (2020). Comparative analysis of completeness of death registration, adult mortality and life expectancy at birth in Brazil at the subnational level. Population Health Metrics 18(Suppl 1): 11.
Round, J.I. (2014). Assessing the demand and supply of statistics in the developing world: Some critical factors. PARIS21 Partnership in Statistics for Development in the 21st Century Discussion Paper 4.
Sankoh, O. and Byass, P. (2014). Time for civil registration with verbal autopsy. Lancet 2(12): e693‒e694.
Serina, P. (2015). A shortened verbal autopsy instrument for use in routine mortality surveillance systems. BMC Medicine 13(302).
Setel, P. (2020). Mortality surveillance during the COVID-19 pandemic. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 98(6): 374.
Setel, P.W., Macfarlane, S.B., Szreter, S., and The Monitoring of Vital Events (MoVE) Writing Group (2007). A scandal of invisibility: Making everyone count by counting everyone. Lancet 370(9598): 1569–1577.
Thomas, L.-M., D’Ambruoso, L., and Balabanova, D. (2018). Verbal autopsy in health policy and systems: A literature review. BMJ Global Health 3(2): e000639.
UNDESA (2014). Principles and recommendations for a vital statistics system revision 3. New York: United Nation, Department of Economic and Social Affairs Statistics Division Statistical Papers, Series M No. 19/Rev. 3.
UNDESA (2019). World population prospects 2019 Volume I: Comprehensive Tables 2019. New York: United Nation.
UNECA (2020). Comprehensive and complete CRVS systems crucial to Africa’s development, says ECA’s Chinganya. Addis Ababa: UNECA.
UNECA (2017). Practical guide on the improvement of death registration and causes of death processes within a civil registration and vital statistics system. Addis Ababa: UNECA.
UNFPA (2022). Advancing Civil Registration for Vital Statistics in the Arab Countries. New York.
UNSD-United Nations Statistical Division (2023). Birth and death registration completeness.
USAID (2020). CRVS strengthening with SAVVY implementation 2016. Washington, DC: USAID .
Vital Strategies and World Health Organization (2020). Revealing the toll of COVID-19: A technical package for rapid mortality surveillance and epidemic response. New York: Vital Strategies.
Weldearegawi, B., Melaku, Y.A., Dinant, G.J., and Spigt, M. (2015). How much do the physician review and InterVA model agree in determining causes of death? A comparative analysis of deaths in rural Ethiopia. BMC Public Health 15(669).
WHO (2017). Manual for the training of interviewers on the use of the 2016 WHO VA instrument. Geneva: World Health Organization.
WHO (2019). Problem analysis approaches, tools for WASH and health working together – a ‘how to’ guide for NTD programmes. Geneva: World Health Organization.
WHO (2011). Review of the WHO Verbal Autopsy (VA) Instrument. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO, Meeting report 19‒20 December 2011 and workshop 21‒22 December 2011.
WHO (2017). Verbal autopsy standards: The 2016 WHO verbal autopsy instrument, V1.5. Geneva: World Health Organization.
WHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific (2005). Health service planning and policy making: A toolkit for nurses and midwives. Manila: WHO office for the Western Pacific.
World Bank (2016). Incentives for improving birth registration coverage: A review of the literature. Washington, DC: World Bank.
World Bank (2023). World Bank country and lending groups, country classification 2023.
World Bank (2018). World Bank List of Economies 2018.
World Bank and WHO (2015). Global civil registration and vital statistics: Scaling Up and investment plan 2015–2024. Washington, D.C: World Bank.
Yokobori, Y., Obara, H., Sugiura, Y., and Kitamura, T. (2020). Gaps in the civil registration and vital statistics systems of low- and middle-income countries and the health sector’s role in improving the situation. Global Health and Medicine 3(4): 243‒245.