Volume 53 - Article 14 | Pages 373–418  

Should we be concerned about low fertility? A discussion of six possible arguments

By Øystein Kravdal

References

Acemoglu, D. and Restrepo, P. (2017). Secular stagnation? The effect of aging on economic growth in the age of automation. American Economic Review 107(5): 174–179.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Alderotti, G., Vignoli, D., Baccini, M., and Matysiak, A. (2021). Employment instability and fertility in Europe: A meta-analysis. Demography 58(3): 871–900.

Weblink:
Download reference:

André, S., Cammu, N., and Meuleman, E. (2025). Fathers, families, and society: A two-decade systematic literature review on the contexts and consequences of paternity and parental leave for fathers. Social Sciences 14(3): 168.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Badolato, L. (2025). The fertility desires–intentions gap in the United States. Population Studies online first.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Balbo, N. and Arpino, B. (2016). The role of family orientations in shaping the effect of fertility on subjective well-being: A propensity score matching approach. Demography 53(4): 955–978.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Barclay, K., Keenan, K., Grundy, E., Kolk, M., and Myrskylä, M. (2016). Reproductive history and post-reproductive mortality: A sibling comparison analysis using Swedish register data. Social Science and Medicine 155: 82–92.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Barclay, K. and Myrskylä, M. (2016). Advanced maternal age and offspring outcomes: Reproductive aging and counterbalancing period trends. Population and Development Review 42: 69–94.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Beaujouan, E. and Berghammer, C. (2019). The gap between lifetime fertility intentions and completed fertility in Europe and the United States: A cohort approach. Population Research and Policy Review 38: 507–535.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Bergsvik, J., Cools, S., and Hart, R.K. (2023). Explaining residential clustering of large families. European Journal of Population 39(1): 13.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Bergsvik, J., Fauske, A., and Hart, R.K. (2021). Can policies stall the fertility fall? A systematic review of the (quasi‐) experimental literature. Population and Development Review 47(4): 913–964.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Berrington, A. (2024). Fertility desires, intentions, and behaviour. In: Schneider, N.F. and Kreyenfeld, M. (eds.). Research handbook on the sociology of the family. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing: 248–262.

Download reference:

Berrington, A. and Pattaro, S. (2014). Educational differences in fertility desires, intentions and behaviour: A life course perspective. Advances in Life Course Research 21: 10–27.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Bittman, M. and Wajcman, J. (2000). The rush hour: The character of leisure time and gender equity. Social Forces 79(1): 165–189.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Bloom, D.E., Canning, D., and Fink, G. (2010). Implications of population ageing for economic growth. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 26(4): 583–612.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Bloom, D.E., Chatterji, S., Kowal, P., Lloyd-Sherlock, P., McKee, M., Rechel, B., and Smith, J.P. (2015). Macroeconomic implications of population ageing and selected policy responses. The Lancet 385(9968): 649–657.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Bodnár, K. and Nerlich, C. (2022). The macroeconomic and fiscal impact of population ageing. Frankfurt am Main: ECB, ECB Occasional Paper 296.

Download reference:

Bongaarts, J. and O’Neill, B.C. (2018). Global warming policy: Is population left out in the cold? Science 361(6403): 650–652.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Bradshaw, C.J. and Brook, B.W. (2014). Human population reduction is not a quick fix for environmental problems. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111(46): 16610–16615.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Brandt, M., Haberkern, K., and Szydlik, M. (2009). Intergenerational help and care in Europe. European Sociological Review 25: 585–601.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Brinton, M.C., Bueno, X., Oláh, L., and Hellum, M. (2018). Postindustrial fertility ideals, intentions, and gender inequality: A comparative qualitative analysis. Population and Development Review 44(2): 281–309.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Butz, W.P. and Ward, M.P. (1979). The emergence of countercyclical US fertility. The American Economic Review 69(3): 318–328.

Download reference:

Cai, J. and Stoyanov, A. (2016). Population aging and comparative advantage. Journal of International Economics 102: 1–21.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Carone, N., Baiocco, R., and Lingiardi, V. (2017). Single fathers by choice using surrogacy: Why men decide to have a child as a single parent. Human Reproduction 32(9): 1871–1879.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Christiaans, T. (2017). On the implications of declining population growth for regional migration. Journal of Economics 122(2): 155–171.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Christiaans, T. (2011). Semi-endogenous growth when population is decreasing. Economics Bulletin 31(3): 2667–2673.

Download reference:

Clark, J. and Ferrer, A. (2019). The effect of house prices on fertility: Evidence from Canada. Economics 13(1): e20190038.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Coleman, D. and Rowthorn, R. (2011). Who’s afraid of population decline? A critical examination of its consequences. Population and Development Review 37: 217–248.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Coleman, D.A. (2002). Replacement migration, or why everyone is going to have to live in Korea: A fable for our times from the United Nations. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences 357(1420): 583–598.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Collaborative Group on Hormonal Factors in Breast Cancer (2002). Breast cancer and breastfeeding: collaborative reanalysis of individual data from 47 epidemiological studies in 30 countries, including 50 302 women with breast cancer and 96 973 women without the disease. The Lancet 360(9328): 187–195.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Commission of the European Communities (2006). Demographic future of Europe: From challenge to opportunity. Brussels: Commission of the European Communities.

Download reference:

Crist, E., Ripple, W.J., Ehrlich, P.R., Rees, W.E., and Wolf, C. (2022). Scientists’ warning on population. Science of the Total Environment 845: 157166.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Cylus, J. and Al Tayara, L. (2021). Health, an ageing labour force, and the economy: Does health moderate the relationship between population age-structure and economic growth? Social Science and Medicine 287: 114353.

Weblink:
Download reference:

DeLyser, G. (2012). At midlife, intentionally childfree women and their experiences of regret. Clinical Social Work Journal 40: 66–74.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Doepke, M. (2015). Gary Becker on the quantity and quality of children. Journal of Demographic Economics 81(1): 59–66.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Downey, B.D. and Condron, D.J. (2004). Playing well with others in kindergarten: The benefit of siblings at home. Journal of Marriage and Family 66(2): 333–350.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Easterlin, R. and Crimmins, E. (1985). The fertility revolution: A supply-demand analysis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Download reference:

Eggertsson, G.B., Lancastre, M., and Summers, L.H. (2019). Aging, output per capita, and secular stagnation. American Economic Review: Insights 1(3): 325–342.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Ehrlich, P. and Holdren, J. (1972). Impact of population growth. In: Riker, R.G. (ed.). Population, resources, and the environment. Washington DC: U.S. Government Printing Office: 365–377.

Download reference:

Elgin, C. and Tumen, S. (2012). Can sustained economic growth and declining population coexist? Economic Modelling 29(5): 1899–1908.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Eurostat (2024). Total fertility rate, 2022 [electronic resource].

Fahey, T. and Spéder, Z. (2004). Fertility and family issues in an enlarged Europe. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.

Download reference:

Felmingham, B., Jackson, N., and Zhang, Q. (2002). Indicative impacts of population decline on the operations of local government in Tasmania. Australasian Journal of Regional Studies 8: 95–109.

Download reference:

Gietel-Basten, S., Rotkirch, A., and Sobotka, T. (2022). Changing the perspective on low birth rates: Why simplistic solutions won’t work. British Medical Journal 379: 072670.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Guetto, R., Alderotti, G., and Vignoli, D. (2025). Can family policies enhance fertility? An ex ante evaluation through factorial survey experiments. Demography 62(1): 311–334.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Hart, R.K. (2015). Earnings and first birth probability among Norwegian men and women 1995–2010. Demographic Research 33(38): 1067–1104.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Headey, D.D. and Hodge, A. (2009). The effect of population growth on economic growth: A meta‐regression analysis of the macroeconomic literature. Population and Development Review 35(2): 221–248.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Hu, Q., Lei, X., and Zhao, B. (2021). Demographic changes and economic growth: Impact and mechanisms. China Economic Journal 14(3): 223–242.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Jeffries, S. and Konnert, C. (2002). Regret and psychological well-being among voluntarily and involuntarily childless women and mothers. The International Journal of Aging and Human Development 54(2): 89–106.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Johnstone, B.D. (2020). Tuition fees, worldwide trends. In: Shin, J.C. and Teixeira, P.N. (eds.). The international encyclopedia of higher education systems and institutions. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands: 2661–2672.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Jones, C.I. (2022). The end of economic growth? Unintended consequences of a declining population. American Economic Review 112(11): 3489–3527.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Jones, G.W. (2019). Ultra-low fertility in East Asia: Policy responses and challenges. Asian Population Studies 15(2): 131–149.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Joutsenniemi, K., Martelin, T., Kestilä, L., Martikainen, P., Pirkola, S., and Koskinen, S. (2007). Living arrangements, heavy drinking and alcohol dependence. Alcohol and Alcoholism 42: 480–491.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kan, M., Zhou, Y., Kolpashnikova, K., Hertog, E., Yoda, S., and Jun, J. (2022). Revisiting the gender revolution: Time on paid work, domestic work, and total work in East Asian and Western societies 1985–2016. Gender and Society 36(3): 368–396.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Keil, T.J. and Andreescu, V. (1999). Fertility policy in Ceausescu’s Romania. Journal of Family History 24(4): 478–492.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kendig, H., Dykstra, P.A., Gaalen, R.I., and Melkas, T. (2007). Health of aging parents and childless individuals. Journal of Family Issues 28(11): 1457–1486.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kleven, H., Landais, C., and Leite-Mariante, G. (2024). The child penalty atlas. Review of Economic Studies rdae104.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Knoester, C. and Eggebeen, D.J. (2006). The effects of the transition to parenthood and subsequent children on men’s well-being and social participation. Journal of Family Issues 27(11): 1532–1560.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kolk, M. (2023). The relationship between life-course accumulated income and childbearing of Swedish men and women born 1940–70. Population Studies 77: 197–215.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Korean Statistical Information Service (2024). Korean Statistical Information Service [electronic resource].

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kornstad, T. and Rønsen, M. (2018). Women’s wages and fertility revisited evidence from Norway. European Journal of Population 34: 491–518.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kotschy, R. and Bloom, D.E. (2023). Population aging and economic growth: From demographic dividend to demographic drag? Bonn: Institute for Labor Economics, IZA Discussion Paper 16337.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kotschy, R., Suarez Urtaza, P., and Sunde, U. (2020). The demographic dividend is more than an education dividend. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117(42): 25982–25984.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kravdal, Ø (2014). The estimation of fertility effects on happiness: Even more difficult than usually acknowledged. European Journal of Population 30(3): 263–290.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kravdal, Ø, Magnus, P., Moum, B., and Høivik, M.L. (2020). Association of childbearing with a short-term reduced risk of Crohn disease in mothers. American Journal of Epidemiology 189(4): 294–304.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Kuruc, K., Vyas, S., Budolfson, M., Geruso, M., and Spears, D. (2023). Population decline: Too small and too slow to influence climate change. SSRN 4535022.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Lambertini, M., Santoro, L., Del Mastro, L., Nguyen, B., Livraghi, L., Ugolini, D., Peccatori, F.A., and Azim Jr, H.A. (2016). Reproductive behaviors and risk of developing breast cancer according to tumor subtype: A systematic review and meta-analysis of epidemiological studies. Cancer Treatment Reviews 49: 65–76.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Lee, H.H. and Shin, K. (2021). Decomposing effects of population aging on economic growth in OECD countries. Asian Economic Papers 20(3): 138–159.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Lee, R. and Mason, A. (2010). Fertility, human capital, and economic growth over the demographic transition. European Journal of Population 26(2): 159–182.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Lee, R., Mason, A., and Network, N.T.A. (2014). Is low fertility really a problem? Population aging, dependency, and consumption. Science 346: 229–234.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Lianos, T.P., Pseiridis, A., and Tsounis, N. (2023). Declining population and GDP growth. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 10(1): 1–9.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Liddle, B. and Casey, G. (2022). Population and energy consumption/carbon emissions: What we know, what we should focus on next. In: Hunter, L.M., Gray, C., and Véron, J. (eds.). International handbook of population and environment. Cham: Springer Nature: 421–438.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Liu, W. and McKibbin, W. (2022). Global macroeconomic impacts of demographic change. The World Economy 45(3): 914–942.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Lutz, W. (2007). Adaptation versus mitigation policies on demographic change. Vienna Yearbook of Population Research 19–25.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Lutz, W., Crespo Cuaresma, J., Kebede, E., Prskawetz, A., Sanderson, W.C., and Striessnig, E. (2019). Education rather than age structure brings demographic dividend. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 116(26): 12798–12803.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Maestas, N., Mullen, K.J., and Powell, D. (2023). The effect of population aging on economic growth, the labor force, and productivity. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 15(2): 306–332.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Magnus, P., Birke, C., Vejrup, K., Haugan, A., Alsaker, E., Daltveit, A.K., and Stoltenberg, C. (2016). Cohort profile update: the Norwegian mother and child cohort study (MoBa. International Journal of Epidemiology 45(2): 382–388.

Weblink:
Download reference:

McDonald, G.W., Forgie, V.E., and MacGregor, C. (2006). Treading lightly: The ecofootprints of New Zealand’s ageing population. Ecological Economics 56: 424–439.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan (2024). Summary of vital statistics [electronic resource].

Mino, K. and Sasaki, H. (2023). Long-run consequences of population decline in an economy with exhaustible resources. Economic Modelling 121: 106212.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Mogstad, M. and Wiswall, M. (2016). Testing the quantity–quality model of fertility: Estimation using unrestricted family size models. Quantitative Economics 7(1): 157–192.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Moore, J. and Abetz, J.S. (2019). What do parents regret about having children? Communicating regrets online. Journal of Family Issues 40(3): 390–412.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Muttarak, R. (2021). Demographic perspectives in research on global environmental change. Population Studies 75(sup1): 77–104.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Myrskylä, M., Hellstrand, J., Lappo, S., Lorenti, A., Nisén, J., Rao, Z., and Tikanmäki, H. (2024). Declining fertility, human capital, and economic sustainability. Rostock: Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research, MPIDR Working paper 2024–002.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Naver, K.V., Lundbye‐Christensen, S., Gorst‐Rasmussen, A., Nilas, L., Secher, N.J., Rasmussen, S., and Ovesen, P. (2011). Parity and risk of diabetes in a Danish nationwide birth cohort. Diabetic Medicine 28(1): 43–47.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Nelson, S.K., Kushlev, K., English, T., Dunn, E.W., and Lyubomirsky, S. (2013). In defense of parenthood: Children are associated with more joy than misery. Psychological Science 24: 3–10.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Nomaguchi, K.N. and Milkie, M.A. (2004). Costs and rewards of children: The effects of becoming a parent on adults’ lives. Journal of Marriage and Family 65(2): 356–374.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Nordic Statistics Database (2024). Fertility rates by reporting country [electronic resource].

Norwegian Government (2025). Declining birth rates in Norway: Development and possible policy measures for young adults [electronic resource].

Park, C.Y., Shin, K., and Kikkawa, A. (2022). Demographic change, technological advance, and growth: A cross-country analysis. Economic Modelling 108: 105742.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Pertold-Gebicka, B. and Spolcova, D. (2022). Family size and subjective well-being in Europe: do more children make parents (un)happy? The Economic and Social Review 53(2): 89–136.

Download reference:

Philipov, D. (2009). Fertility intentions and outcomes: The role of policies to close the gap. European Journal of Population 25: 355–361.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Piotrowski, K. (2021). How many parents regret having children and how it is linked to their personality and health: Two studies with national samples in Poland. PLoS ONE 16(7): 0254163.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Piotrowski, K., Naude, L., Sanna, K., Szramka-Pawlak, B., Kwarcińska, K., and Dzielińska, M. (2024). Perceptions of parenting among parents who regret having a child: a mixed-methods study. Journal of Family Studies 30(3): 461–484.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Prevention, Centers for Disease Control and (2024). Births, provisional data for 2023.

Raybould, A. and Sear, R. (2021). Children of the (gender) revolution: A theoretical and empirical synthesis of how gendered division of labour influences fertility. Population Studies 75(2): 169–190.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Ross, S. and McDonald, I.M. (2002). Would a decrease in fertility be a threat to living standards in Australia? Australian Economic Review 35(1): 29–44.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Russo, I.H. and Russo, J. (2007). Primary prevention of breast cancer by hormone-induced differentiation. Recent Results in Cancer Research 174: 111–130.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Salehi, F., Dunfield, L., Philips, K.P., Krewski, D., and Vanderhyden, B.C. (2008). Risk factors for ovarian cancer: An overview with emphasis on hormonal factors. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, Part B: Critical Reviews 11: 301–321.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Santow, G. and Bracher, M. (2001). Deferment of the first birth and fluctuation fertility in Sweden. European Journal of Population 17: 343–363.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Sasaki, H. and Hoshida, K. (2017). The effects of negative population growth: An analysis using a semiendogenous R&D growth model. Macroeconomic Dynamics 21(7): 1545–1560.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Sciubba, J.D. (2023). Population ageing and national security in Asia. International Affairs 99(5): 2119–2136.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Seshamani, M. and Gray, A.M. (2004). A longitudinal study of the effects of age and time to death on hospital costs. Journal of Health Economics 23(2): 217–235.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Sheppard, P. and Monden, C. (2020). When does family size matter? Sibship size, socioeconomic status and education in England. Evolutionary Human Sciences 2: 51.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Sigle, W. (2023). Like high cholesterol, population decline is a problem, but not in the way you might think. Vienna Yearbook of Population Research 21: 15–20.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Skilton, M.R., Sérusclat, A., Begg, L.M., Moulin, P., and Bonnet, F. (2009). Parity and carotid atherosclerosis in men and women: Insights into the roles of childbearing and child-rearing. Stroke 40: 1152–1157.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Sørensen, N.O., Marcussen, S., Backhausen, M.G., Juhl, M., Schmidt, L., Tydén, T., and Hegaard, H.K. (2016). Fertility awareness and attitudes towards parenthood among Danish university college students. Reproductive Health 13: 1–10.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Strijbosch, K. (2015). Single and the city: State influences on intimate relationships of young, single, well‐educated women in Singapore. Journal of Marriage and Family 77(5): 1108–1125.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Taguchi, H. and Latjin, M. (2023). The effects of demographic dynamics on economic growth in EU economies: A panel vector autoregressive approach. Journal of Population Ageing 16(3): 569–588.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Testa, M.R. (2007). Childbearing preferences and family issues in Europe: Evidence from the Eurobarometer survey. Vienna Yearbook of Population Research 5: 357–379.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Trimarchi, A. and Van Bavel, J. (2020). Partners’ educational characteristics and fertility: Disentangling the effects of earning potential and unemployment risk on second births. European Journal of Population 36: 439–464.

Weblink:
Download reference:

United Nations (2024). World population prospects 2024 [electronic resource]. New York: Department of Economic and Social affairs.

Weblink:
Download reference:

United Nations Population Fund (2025). The real fertility crisis: The pursuit of reproductive agency in a changing world. New York, State of World Population.

Download reference:

Vasireddy, S., Berrington, A., Kuang, B., and Kulu, H. (2023). Education and fertility: A review of recent research in Europe. Comparative Population Studies 48.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Vignoli, D. (2013). The role of work experience in shaping the entry into motherhood: A study for Italy. Population Review 52(2).

Weblink:
Download reference:

Wang, Q., Yang, T., Li, R., and Wang, L. (2023). Population aging redefines the economic growth-carbon emissions nexus, energy consumption-carbon emissions nexus-Evidence from 36 OECD countries. Energy and Environment 34(4): 946–970.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Wang, X.T., Kruger, D.J., and Wilke, A. (2009). Life history variables and risk-taking propensity. Evolution and Human Behavior 30(2): 77–84.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Weber, H. and Sciubba, J.D. (2019). The effect of population growth on the environment: evidence from European regions. European Journal of Population 35: 379–402.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Wenger, G.C., Dykstra, P.A., Melkas, T., and Knipscheer, K.C.M. (2007). Social embeddedness and late-life parenthood – community activity, close ties, and support networks. Journal of Family Issues 28: 1419–1456.

Weblink:
Download reference:

White, M.P. and Dolan, P. (2009). Accounting for the richness of daily activities. Psychological Science 20: 1000–1008.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Wijk, D.C. (2024). House prices and fertility: Can the Dutch housing crisis explain the post‐2010 fertility decline? Population, Space and Place 30(7): 2787.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Wijk, D.C., Valk, H.A., and Liefbroer, A.C. (2022). Economic precariousness and the transition to parenthood: A dynamic and multidimensional approach. European Journal of Population 38(3): 457–483.

Weblink:
Download reference:

YouGov (2021). One in twelve parents say they regret having children [electronic resource].

Zeman, K., Beaujouan, É, Brzozowska, Z., and Sobotka, T. (2018). Cohort fertility decline in low fertility countries: Decomposition using parity progression ratios. Demographic Research 38(25): 651–690.

Weblink:
Download reference:

Back to the article