Volume 33 - Article 3 | Pages 65–92  

Educational differences in early childbearing: A cross-national comparative study

By James M. Raymo, Marcia Carlson, Alicia VanOrman, Sojung Lim, Brienna Perelli-Harris, Miho Iwasawa

Abstract

Background: Recent research on fertility in industrialized countries focuses primarily on delayed childbearing, despite the facts that large numbers of women continue to enter parenthood at relatively young ages and that early childbearing has been linked to economic disadvantage.

Objective: This cross-national comparative study describes relationships between women's educational attainment and young age at first birth and evaluates the extent to which these differences have changed over time for women born 1955-1981.

Methods: Defining 'early' childbearing as the age by which 20% of first births have occurred to women in a given birth cohort and country, we describe differences in early childbearing by educational attainment across three cohorts of women in 20 countries.

Results: We find a strong negative educational gradient in early childbearing across all 20 countries and some evidence of an increase in the relative prevalence of early childbearing among the least-educated women. In 10 countries, the relative prevalence of early childbearing among women with low education is significantly higher for one or both of the more recent birth cohorts compared to the earliest cohort. However, many countries show no significant change, and in one country (Poland) there is modest evidence of a decreasing educational gap.

Conclusions: Evidence that educational differences in early childbearing have grown in some countries is generally consistent with the notion of family bifurcation and 'diverging destinies' by socioeconomic status. However, the pattern is not universal and future work should examine the various factors that shape these patterns, including the role of public policies.

Author’s Affiliation

• James M. Raymo - Princeton University, United States of America EMAIL
• Marcia Carlson - University of Wisconsin–Madison, United States of America EMAIL
• Alicia VanOrman - University of Wisconsin–Madison, United States of America EMAIL
• Sojung Lim - Utah State University, United States of America EMAIL
• Brienna Perelli-Harris - University of Southampton, United Kingdom EMAIL
• Miho Iwasawa - National Institute of Population and Social Security Research, Japan EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

An alternative version of the second demographic transition? Changing pathways to first marriage in Japan
Volume 49 - Article 16

Educational Differences in Divorce in Japan
Volume 28 - Article 6

Marital Dissolution in Japan: Recent Trends and Patterns
Volume 11 - Article 14

Increases in shared custody after divorce in the United States
Volume 46 - Article 38

Socioeconomic differentials in fertility in South Korea
Volume 44 - Article 39

Marriage intentions, desires, and pathways to later and less marriage in Japan
Volume 44 - Article 3

The role of education in the intersection of partnership transitions and motherhood in Europe and the United States
Volume 39 - Article 27

Cross-national differences in women's repartnering behaviour in Europe: The role of individual demographic characteristics
Volume 37 - Article 8

Exploring social norms around cohabitation: The life course, individualization, and culture: Introduction to Special Collection: "Focus on Partnerships: Discourses on cohabitation and marriage throughout Europe and Australia"
Volume 33 - Article 25

Commitment and the changing sequence of cohabitation, childbearing, and marriage: Insights from qualitative research in the UK
Volume 33 - Article 12

Changes in partnership patterns across the life course: An examination of 14 countries in Europe and the United States
Volume 33 - Article 6

Living alone in Japan: Relationships with happiness and health
Volume 32 - Article 46

Towards a new understanding of cohabitation: Insights from focus group research across Europe and Australia
Volume 31 - Article 34

Ukraine: On the border between old and new in uncertain times
Volume 19 - Article 29

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Fertility differences across immigrant generations in the United Kingdom
Volume 52 - Article 33    | Keywords: event history analysis, fertility, immigrant, second generation, United Kingdom

Amish fertility in the United States: Comparative evidence from the American Community Survey and Amish population registries
Volume 52 - Article 26    | Keywords: American Community Survey (ACS), Amish, fertility, natural fertility, total fertility rate (TFR)

Examining the relationships between education, coresidential unions, and the fertility gap by simulating the reproductive life courses of Dutch women
Volume 52 - Article 24    | Keywords: contraception, education, fertility, GGS, life course, LISS, microsimulation, Netherlands, physiology, unions

Demographic convergence in marriage timing: Intersecting gender and educational expansion
Volume 52 - Article 14    | Keywords: age at marriage, convergence, cross-country, education, gender, union formation

Job creation, job destruction, and fertility in Germany
Volume 52 - Article 13    | Keywords: fertility, gender, Germany, job creation, job destruction, labor market, spatial modelling, unemployment