Volume 38 - Article 29 | Pages 773–842 Editor's Choice Author has provided data and code for replicating results Article has associated letter

Gompertz, Makeham, and Siler models explain Taylor's law in human mortality data

By Joel E. Cohen, Christina Bohk, Roland Rau

Print this page  Facebook  Twitter


Date received:14 Mar 2017
Date published:01 Mar 2018
Word count:8197
Keywords:Gompertz mortality, Makeham, mean mortality, mortality, mortality model, Siler model, Taylor's law
Additional files:readme.38-29 (text file, 5 kB)
 demographic-research.38-29 (zip file, 92 kB)


Background: Taylor’s law (TL) states a linear relationship on logarithmic scales between the variance and the mean of a nonnegative quantity. TL has been observed in spatiotemporal contexts for the population density of hundreds of species including humans. TL also describes temporal variation in human mortality in developed countries, but no explanation has been proposed.

Objective: To understand why and to what extent TL describes temporal variation in human mortality, we examine whether the mortality models of Gompertz, Makeham, and Siler are consistent with TL. We also examine how strongly TL differs between observed and modeled mortality, between women and men, and among countries.

Methods: We analyze how well each mortality model explains TL fitted to observed occurrence–exposure death rates by comparing three features: the log–log linearity of the temporal variance as a function of the temporal mean, the age profile, and the slope of TL. We support some empirical findings from the Human Mortality Database with mathematical proofs.

Results: TL describes modeled mortality better than observed mortality and describes Gompertz mortality best. The age profile of TL is closest between observed and Siler mortality. The slope of TL is closest between observed and Makeham mortality. The Gompertz model predicts TL with a slope of exactly 2 if the modal age at death increases linearly with time and the parameter that specifies the growth rate of mortality with age is constant in time. Observed mortality obeys TL with a slope generally less than 2. An explanation is that, when the parameters of the Gompertz model are estimated from observed mortality year by year, both the modal age at death and the growth rate of mortality with age change over time.

Conclusions: TL describes human mortality well in developed countries because their mortality schedules are approximated well by classical mortality models, which we have shown to obey TL.

Contribution: We provide the first theoretical linkage between three classical demographic models of mortality and TL.

Author's Affiliation

Joel E. Cohen - Rockefeller University, United States of America [Email]
Christina Bohk - Max-Planck-Institut für Demografische Forschung, Germany [Email]
Roland Rau - Universität Rostock, Germany [Email]

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

» Taylor's power law in human mortality
Volume 33 - Article 21

» Is the fraction of people ever born who are currently alive rising or falling?
Volume 30 - Article 56

» Minor gradient in mortality by education at the highest ages: An application of the Extinct-Cohort method
Volume 29 - Article 19

» Life expectancy: Lower and upper bounds from surviving fractions and remaining life expectancy
Volume 24 - Article 11

» Life expectancy is the death-weighted average of the reciprocal of the survival-specific force of mortality
Volume 22 - Article 5

» Constant global population with demographic heterogeneity
Volume 18 - Article 14

» Seasonal mortality in Denmark: the role of sex and age
Volume 9 - Article 9

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

» Attrition in heterogeneous cohorts
Volume 23 - Article 26    | Keywords: Makeham, mortality

» Mexican mortality 1990‒2016: Comparison of unadjusted and adjusted estimates
Volume 44 - Article 30    | Keywords: mortality

» Using race- and age-specific COVID-19 case data to investigate the determinants of the excess COVID-19 mortality burden among Hispanic Americans
Volume 44 - Article 29    | Keywords: mortality

» Age and COVID-19 mortality: A comparison of Gompertz doubling time across countries and causes of death
Volume 44 - Article 16    | Keywords: mortality

» Estimation of older adult mortality from imperfect data: A comparative review of methods using Burkina Faso censuses
Volume 43 - Article 38    | Keywords: mortality