Volume 54 - Article 25 | Pages 779–820  

Economic insecurity and material deprivation: Coping strategies among couple families with and without small children in Europe

By Raffaele Grotti, Davide Gritti, Stefani Scherer

Abstract

Background: Families in Europe are increasingly exposed to economic insecurity, which may heighten their risk of material deprivation. Coping strategies – typically involving employment by family members – may help mitigate such risks. However, the ability to adopt such strategies and their effectiveness may depend on the welfare context and the presence of small children, an aspect that remains under-investigated.

Objective: This paper examines the role of the female partner’s employment as a coping strategy against material deprivation in response to the male partner’s loss of earnings, distinguishing between buffering (stable employment) and resilience (entry into employment).

Methods: We used longitudinal EU-SILC data (2004–2019) for 31 European countries and applied first-difference models. We distinguished between couples with and without children aged 0–5 years, and compared outcomes across six European country clusters: Nordic, Anglo-Saxon, Continental, Southern, Central-Eastern, and Baltic. We analysed both the prevalence and effectiveness of buffering and resilience strategies.

Results: Male earnings loss is associated with a substantial increase in material deprivation, regardless of the presence of small children. Buffering is more prevalent among families without small children and in more defamilised contexts, such as Nordic and Continental European countries. Resilience is more frequent among families with small children, especially in Baltic countries. Regarding effectiveness, buffering mitigates the impact of earnings loss in some countries, regardless of the presence of small children. By contrast, resilience is largely ineffective.

Contribution: This study shows that although stable female employment is an effective coping strategy, employment activation remains fragile and highly context-dependent. Families with small children are more likely to rely on employment activation than families without small children; however, the capacity of employment activation to cushion material deprivation is limited and uncertain. Thus, policy efforts should prioritise support for maternal employment continuity.

Author’s Affiliation

• Raffaele Grotti - Università degli Studi di Trento, Italy EMAIL
• Davide Gritti - Università degli Studi di Trento, Italy EMAIL
• Stefani Scherer - Università degli Studi di Trento, Italy EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Gender inequality in domestic chores over ten months of the UK COVID-19 pandemic: Heterogeneous adjustments to partners’ changes in working hours
Volume 46 - Article 19

Retraditionalisation? Work patterns of families with children during the pandemic in Italy
Volume 45 - Article 31

Similar articles in Demographic Research

Winter life expectancy reduction in Europe
Volume 54 - Article 26    | Keywords: Europe, excess winter deaths, excess winter mortality paradox, life expectancy, mortality, summer, weekly mortality data, winter

Uncertainty, resilience, and fertility: Perceived capacity to overcome loss of employment and fertility intentions in Sweden, 2021
Volume 53 - Article 31    | Keywords: economic uncertainties, fertility decline, fertility intention, globalization, resilience, Sweden

Attitudes toward child well-being in diverse families across Europe
Volume 53 - Article 11    | Keywords: attitudes, children, Europe, European Social Survey, family, gender, same-sex couples, single parenthood, stepfamily

How do fathers and mothers allocate their leisure time? Patterns and inequalities across 13 European countries
Volume 52 - Article 31    | Keywords: Europe, gender inequalities, parents, space-time dynamics, time use

Family and social resilience: A scoping review of the empirical literature
Volume 52 - Article 27    | Keywords: family resilience, resilience, scoping review, social resilience