Volume 55 - Article 8 | Pages 275–306  

The intergenerational association between migration and early childhood development in Germany: A comparative cross-sectional study of forced and voluntary migrant families (2004–2021)

By Valeriia Heidemann, Sabine Zinn, Louise Biddle

Abstract

Background: Family migration shapes early childhood development (ECD), but the link between parental voluntary versus forced migration experiences and ECD remains underexplored. Germany, with its diverse migration streams, offers an opportunity to investigate this interrelation.

Objective: This study examines the link between parental migration status and ECD of children aged 2–4 and investigates whether the association between parental mental health and ECD differs by migration background.

Methods: Using the German Socio-Economic Panel (2004–2021; N = 1,826), we fit multivariate linear regression models, comparing ECD between children of voluntary and forced migrants. ECD is measured using an adapted version of the Vineland Adaptive Behaviour Scales. Further models account for maternal and paternal mental health scores, using the Mental Component Summary (MCS).

Results: Children of forced migrants showed lower early childhood development across all domains compared to children of voluntary migrants, with the largest gaps observed in gross motor skills (β = −0.354, 95% CI: −0.472, −0.237) and social relations (β = −0.239, 95% CI: −0.356, −0.122). Adjustment for parental mental health attenuated these differences but did not eliminate them. Interaction analyses provided no evidence that the association between parental mental health and ECD differed by migration background.

Conclusions: Developmental disparities associated with a forced migration background emerge early and persist beyond parental mental health, indicating that individual family resources do not fully explain these inequalities.

Contribution: This study demonstrates that early developmental inequalities among children of forced migrants are not primarily driven by parental mental health, highlighting the importance of broader structural conditions.

Author’s Affiliation

• Valeriia Heidemann - Deutsches Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung (DIW), Germany EMAIL
• Sabine Zinn - Deutsches Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung (DIW), Germany EMAIL
• Louise Biddle - Deutsches Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung (DIW), Germany EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Coronavirus and care: How the coronavirus crisis affected fathers' involvement in Germany
Volume 44 - Article 4

Similar articles in Demographic Research

Resilience or social reproduction? Parental job loss and children’s prosocial development and caregiving after the Great Recession
Volume 55 - Article 1    | Keywords: caregiving, gender, Great Recession, prosocial behaviour, resilience, social reproduction

Spatial perspective on environmental migration: Empirical insights from a spatiotemporal approach in the United States, 1970–2010
Volume 54 - Article 27    | Keywords: environmental migration, migration, net migration rate, rural-urban inequality, spatial analysis, United States of America

Economic insecurity and material deprivation: Coping strategies among couple families with and without small children in Europe
Volume 54 - Article 25    | Keywords: added worker effect, buffer, earnings loss, economic insecurity, Europe, female employment, material deprivation, resilience

Non-intact families and adolescents’ family satisfaction during the Second Demographic Transition: A test of the institutionalization hypothesis
Volume 54 - Article 21    | Keywords: adolescence, divorce, families, family structure, parental separation, satisfaction, single-parent families, union dissolution

Return migration and educational investments in children in China: Hukou differences and the role of parental coresidence
Volume 54 - Article 20    | Keywords: China, coresidence, hukou, human capital, left-behind children, migrant children, parents, return migration