Volume 18 - Article 15 | Pages 437–442  

The reporting of statistical significance in scientific journals: A reflexion

By Jan M. Hoem

Abstract

Scientific journals in most empirical disciplines have regulations about how authors should report the precision of their estimates of model parameters and other model elements. Some journals that overlap fully or partly with the field of demography demand as a strict prerequisite for publication that a p-value, a confidence interval, or a standard deviation accompany any parameter estimate. I feel that this rule is sometimes applied in an overly mechanical manner. Standard deviations and p-values produced routinely by general-purpose software are taken at face value and included without questioning, and features that have too high a p-value or too large a standard deviation are too easily disregarded as being without interest because they appear not to be statistically significant. In my opinion authors should be discouraged from adhering to this practice, and flexibility rather than rigidity should be encouraged in the reporting of statistical significance. I would also encourage thoughtful rather than mechanical use of p-values, standard deviations, confidence intervals, and the like.

Author’s Affiliation

• Jan M. Hoem - Stockholms Universitet, Sweden EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Immigrant fertility in Sweden, 2000-2011: A descriptive note
Volume 30 - Article 30

Recent fertility patterns of Finnish women by union status: A descriptive account
Volume 28 - Article 14

Levels of recent union formation : Six European countries compared
Volume 22 - Article 9

The negative educational gradients in Romanian fertility
Volume 22 - Article 4

Overview Chapter 8: The impact of public policies on European fertility
Volume 19 - Article 10

Summary and general conclusions: Childbearing Trends and Policies in Europe
Volume 19 - Article 2

Preface: Childbearing Trends and Policies in Europe
Volume 19 - Article 1

Marriage formation as a process intermediary between migration and childbearing
Volume 18 - Article 21

Generations and Gender Survey (GGS): Towards a better understanding of relationships and processes in the life course
Volume 17 - Article 14

Anticipatory analysis and its alternatives in life-course research: Part 2: Marriage and first birth
Volume 15 - Article 17

Anticipatory analysis and its alternatives in life-course research: Part 1: Education and first childbearing
Volume 15 - Article 16

Educational attainment and ultimate fertility among Swedish women born in 1955-59
Volume 14 - Article 16

Education and childlessness: The relationship between educational field, educational level, and childlessness among Swedish women born in 1955-59
Volume 14 - Article 15

Social differentials in speed-premium effects in childbearing in Sweden
Volume 14 - Article 4

Why does Sweden have such high fertility?
Volume 13 - Article 22

Childbearing patterns for Swedish mothers of twins, 1961-1999
Volume 11 - Article 15